UFTPD-054 citable reproducibility review packet

UFTPD-054-citable-reproducibility-review-packet.json

{
  "rung": "UFTPD-054",
  "packet_id": "uftpd054_citable_reproducibility_review_packet",
  "route_id": "uftpd053_citable_reproducibility_review_route",
  "packet_label": "citable-reproducibility-review-packet",
  "target_commit": "24c21000341f1938ded8e384070a3da925d41e92",
  "baseline_workflow_run_id": 27037214864,
  "release_tag": "uftpd-container-review-v1",
  "release_url": "https://github.com/Unified-Field-Theory-Research/unified-field-theory-physical-promotion-dossier-from-finite-capacity-causal-networks/releases/tag/uftpd-container-review-v1",
  "included_files": [
    "reproduction/UFTPD-054-citable-reproducibility-review-packet.md",
    "reproduction/UFTPD-054-citable-review-response-template.md",
    "reproduction/UFTPD-053-citable-reproducibility-review-route.md",
    "reproduction/UFTPD-052-public-release-review-no-response-audit.md",
    "reproduction/UFTPD-050-public-release-artifact-review-surface.md",
    "reproduction/UFTPD-049-independent-response-template.md"
  ],
  "response_template_path": "reproduction/UFTPD-054-citable-review-response-template.md",
  "reviewer_reproduction_commands": [
    "make test-fast",
    "make lean-build",
    "cargo run --quiet --bin uftpd_candidate_snapshot"
  ],
  "required_submission_fields": [
    "reviewer-name-or-organization",
    "public-profile-or-organization-url",
    "independence-statement",
    "conflict-of-interest-statement",
    "reviewed-route-id",
    "reviewed-target-commit",
    "reviewed-release-url",
    "reviewed-clean-checkout-run-id",
    "command-transcripts-if-reproduced",
    "tool-versions-and-os-or-container-details",
    "returned-log-or-artifact-sha256-values",
    "local-modification-statement",
    "signed-timestamp-and-public-response-url"
  ],
  "expected_snapshot_hash": "373dfc4a41922081",
  "route_selected": true,
  "packet_prepared": true,
  "response_template_prepared": true,
  "external_submission_performed": false,
  "citable_archive_created": false,
  "third_party_response_received": false,
  "returned_artifact_hashes_recorded": false,
  "independent_reproduction_success": false,
  "review_acceptance_claim": false,
  "empirical_adequacy_claim": false,
  "physical_validation_claim": false,
  "completed_unified_field_theory_claim": false
}

UFTPD-054-citable-reproducibility-review-packet.md

UFTPD-054 Citable Reproducibility Review Packet

Packet

• packet id: uftpd054_citable_reproducibility_review_packet
• route id: uftpd053_citable_reproducibility_review_route
• packet label: citable-reproducibility-review-packet
• target commit: 24c21000341f1938ded8e384070a3da925d41e92
• baseline workflow run id: 27037214864
• release tag: uftpd-container-review-v1
• release URL: https://github.com/Unified-Field-Theory-Research/unified-field-theory-physical-promotion-dossier-from-finite-capacity-causal-networks/releases/tag/uftpd-container-review-v1
• response template path: reproduction/UFTPD-054-citable-review-response-template.md

Included Files

• reproduction/UFTPD-054-citable-reproducibility-review-packet.md
• reproduction/UFTPD-054-citable-review-response-template.md
• reproduction/UFTPD-053-citable-reproducibility-review-route.md
• reproduction/UFTPD-052-public-release-review-no-response-audit.md
• reproduction/UFTPD-050-public-release-artifact-review-surface.md
• reproduction/UFTPD-049-independent-response-template.md

Reviewer Reproduction Commands

make test-fast
make lean-build
cargo run --quiet --bin uftpd_candidate_snapshot

Expected candidate snapshot hash: 373dfc4a41922081.

Required Submission Fields

• reviewer-name-or-organization
• public-profile-or-organization-url
• independence-statement
• conflict-of-interest-statement
• reviewed-route-id
• reviewed-target-commit
• reviewed-release-url
• reviewed-clean-checkout-run-id
• command-transcripts-if-reproduced
• tool-versions-and-os-or-container-details
• returned-log-or-artifact-sha256-values
• local-modification-statement
• signed-timestamp-and-public-response-url

Fail-Closed Boundary

• route selected: true
• packet prepared: true
• response template prepared: true
• external submission performed: false
• citable archive created: false
• third-party response received: false
• returned artifact hashes recorded: false
• independent reproduction success: false
• review acceptance: false
• empirical adequacy: false
• physical validation: false
• completed unified field theory: false

Next Action

Close UFTPD-055 by dispatching or archiving this packet through a citable external channel, then record the public URL. Packet preparation alone is not external submission, archive creation, review acceptance, independent reproduction success, empirical adequacy, physical validation, or a completed unified field theory.

UFTPD-054-citable-review-response-template.md

UFTPD-054 Citable Review Response Template

Reviewer Identity

• reviewer-name-or-organization:
• public-profile-or-organization-url:

Independence Statement

• independent of repository author and current Codex operator:
• conflict-of-interest statement:

Reviewed Artifacts

• reviewed route id: uftpd053_citable_reproducibility_review_route
• Reviewed Target Commit: 24c21000341f1938ded8e384070a3da925d41e92
• reviewed release URL: https://github.com/Unified-Field-Theory-Research/unified-field-theory-physical-promotion-dossier-from-finite-capacity-causal-networks/releases/tag/uftpd-container-review-v1
• reviewed clean-checkout run id: 27037214864

Reproduction Attempt

• commands run:
• command transcripts:
• tool versions and OS or container details:
• local modifications statement:

Returned Hashes

• reproduction-test-fast log SHA-256:
• reproduction-lean-build log SHA-256:
• reproduction-candidate-snapshot log SHA-256:
• candidate snapshot hash observed:
• snapshot_hash=373dfc4a41922081 matched:

Review Result

• artifacts reviewed:
• reproduction attempted:
• reproduction outputs matched:
• concerns or deviations:
• signed timestamp:
• public response URL or archive URL:

This response does not by itself prove physical validation, empirical adequacy, prediction success, review acceptance, or a completed unified field theory. Those claims require the dossier gates to record and verify returned artifacts and evidence boundaries separately.