Hi Brian,
Back in 2015 and again in 2022-2024, I studied 1120 graphite art pencils from every major manufacturer. I was disappointed to find that sets such as Derwent Graphic didn't seem to have the quality or value (darkness) consistency I wanted. I started drawing in 2014, so I had little experience as an artist. Why did my Derwent Graphic grade B pencil seem to have the same darkness as my Derwent Graphic 3B pencil? Why was the 4B exactly the same as the 6B in its performance on paper? Why were some of the leads scratchy? Did my inexperience in the discipline give me unreasonable expectations? I was hardly an artist. But I was (and am) a scientist. I resolved to find an answer to my questions.
I found grade varied tremendously from one manufacturer to another. Why? I did some simple experiments. I found darkness and softness are NOT interchangeable terms. I found a pencil could be very dark yet hard as nails and leave little graphite on paper (I measured the amount of graphite deposited), and a pencil